TikTok’s Future in Jeopardy After Supreme Court Arguments: What Comes Next?

The fate of TikTok in the United States hangs in the balance. On Friday, January 10, 2025, the Supreme Court heard arguments about a law requiring TikTok to sever ties with its Chinese parent company, ByteDance, or face a nationwide ban starting January 19, 2025. With the clock ticking, TikTok has announced it will shut down operations in the U.S. if the law takes effect.

What Happened at the Supreme Court?

The Supreme Court justices appeared skeptical of TikTok's arguments against the law. The bipartisan law was designed to address national security concerns over ByteDance’s ownership, including fears that the Chinese government could exploit user data or manipulate content for espionage or influence campaigns.

Key moments from the hearing:

• National Security Risks: Justice Brett Kavanaugh raised concerns about the potential for ByteDance to provide sensitive data to the Chinese government or influence American users, particularly those in key national security roles.
• Skepticism of TikTok’s Free Speech Argument: Both conservative and liberal justices seemed doubtful of TikTok’s claim that the ban violated First Amendment protections, emphasizing that the law targeted foreign ownership, not speech.
• No Indications of a Stay: TikTok’s request for an administrative stay to delay enforcement until the new administration takes over was seen as unlikely. Legal analysts suggest the court is unlikely to set a precedent for delaying enforcement due to political changes.

The Supreme Court is expected to deliver its decision before the January 19 deadline, with many legal experts predicting that the court will uphold the law.

What Opportunities Remain for TikTok?

If the ban is upheld, TikTok will face extremely limited options. Here are the two main possibilities:

1) Sell U.S. Operations

The most straightforward path for TikTok to continue operating in the United States is to divest its U.S. operations to an American company. However, this option comes with significant complications:

• ByteDance Resistance: ByteDance, TikTok’s China-based parent company, has historically resisted calls to sell its U.S. operations. The company has cited national security laws in China that could prevent or significantly delay such a sale.
• Chinese Government Approval: Even if ByteDance agrees to sell, China’s government must approve the transaction. China has implemented strict controls on the export of technology, including algorithms like TikTok’s, which are central to its operation. This raises the possibility that Beijing may block or stall the sale as part of its own geopolitical strategy.
• Potential Buyers: Major U.S. tech companies and investor groups have expressed interest in acquiring TikTok. However, any deal would require negotiations over ownership of TikTok’s algorithm, intellectual property, and data security measures—making a swift resolution unlikely.

2) Trump Administration Intervention

President-elect Donald Trump has publicly expressed interest in saving TikTok. He even filed an unusual brief with the Supreme Court requesting the court delay action until he takes office. His administration could take the following actions:

Delay Enforcement: Trump could declare that his administration will not enforce the law, buying TikTok time to negotiate a sale or restructure its U.S. operations. However, this approach is fraught with legal risks:

• Liability for U.S. Companies: Companies like Apple and Google could still face fines of $5,000 per user for maintaining TikTok on their app stores if the law remains in effect. This risk may not be worth it for these organizations.
• Long-Term Uncertainty: Even if Trump declines to enforce the law, subsequent administrations could revisit and enforce penalties against companies that violate it, creating a risky legal environment.

Broker a Sale: Trump has suggested he might attempt to facilitate a deal between ByteDance and a U.S. buyer. While this could provide a path forward, it would require cooperation from ByteDance and the Chinese government—both of which are significant hurdles.

Broader Implications

This case goes beyond TikTok and raises critical questions about the future of social media, global technology governance, and national security:

• Precedent for Social Media Regulation: While TikTok’s unique ownership structure makes it an outlier, the case could set a precedent for regulating foreign-owned platforms in the U.S.
• Impact on U.S.-China Relations: The case is a flashpoint in broader tensions between the U.S. and China over technology and trade.
• User Rights: The legal battle highlights the challenges of balancing national security concerns with protecting digital free expression.
• Business Strategy: Many US businesses and individuals generate thousands or even millions of dollars solely from TikTok, showing the risks of a centralized dependency on a single platform for revenue and audience engagement, especially one that is foreign owned.

What’s Next?

The Supreme Court is likely to issue its decision within days, and if the ban is upheld, TikTok will face significant hurdles. ByteDance must decide whether to sell its U.S. operations quickly, while Trump’s administration may attempt to intervene when he takes office on January 20. The outcome will have far-reaching consequences for TikTok’s 170 million American users and the broader tech industry.

Stay tuned for updates as this pivotal case unfolds.

‍